Hon. Alexander Afenyo-Markin’s GH¢15 million defamation suit against Sammy Gyamfi was thrown out on procedural grounds, not because the court said Gyamfi was right. But in politics, technical victories do not always save reputations.
The public reaction has been brutal. On social media, many users mocked the Minority Leader after the ruling, turning a legal setback into a story about lost authority and poor judgement. The NDC did not need to say much; the internet did the work.
The real problem
Afenyo-Markin had every right to sue. Being called an “extortionist” is a serious allegation, and no public figure should be expected to absorb it silently.
But leadership is judged by more than legal rights. A Minority Leader’s job is to keep the government under pressure, not to become the headline. Instead of the NPP driving the conversation on GoldBod, the economy and accountability, the party is now defending its leader’s courtroom misstep.
Pressure from within
The most dangerous voices are not from the NDC. Commentators such as Emmanuel Kotin have openly called for Afenyo-Markin to resign to protect the NPP’s image, while lawyer Ross Osei Owusu has questioned whether he should remain Minority Leader if he cannot clear his name.
That is how leadership crises begin: not with a formal challenge, but with allies quietly asking whether the leader has become a liability.
What he must do
Afenyo-Markin has two choices.
He can refile, appeal and keep fighting, risking months of headlines, mockery and distraction. Or he can step back from the personal war, refocus on Parliament, and prove that the Minority’s agenda is bigger than Sammy Gyamfi.
The second option is stronger. He should let his lawyers handle the law quietly, while he returns to the floor with sharper questions, stronger opposition and a clearer national message.
The verdict
Afenyo-Markin does not need to win a defamation case to survive. He needs to win back public confidence and his party’s focus.
If he continues to make this about himself, the NPP may soon be forced to ask an uncomfortable question: is he still the best man to lead the fight, or has the fight consumed the man?

